Highlights

  • Who is the real majority in India?
  • A look at the FPTP system of voting

Latest news

Relief Efforts Underway as 20,000 Families Displaced in Pakistan Operation

Relief Efforts Underway as 20,000 Families Displaced in Pakistan Operation

Punjab Police busts ISI-backed Babbar Khalsa module

Punjab Police busts ISI-backed Babbar Khalsa module

Punjab Police busts major Babbar Khalsa terror module

Punjab Police busts major Babbar Khalsa terror module

Zelenskyy Engages Berlin Ahead of Trump-Putin Summit

Zelenskyy Engages Berlin Ahead of Trump-Putin Summit

Trump’s Diplomacy: Reassigning Loyal Advisors Amid Challenges

Trump’s Diplomacy: Reassigning Loyal Advisors Amid Challenges

Punjab DGP reviews security ahead of Independence Day

Punjab DGP reviews security ahead of Independence Day

South Korea’s Former First Lady Kim Keon Hee Arrested Amid Scandal

South Korea’s Former First Lady Kim Keon Hee Arrested Amid Scandal

Khalid Jamil Appointed Indian Football Team Head Coach

Khalid Jamil Appointed Indian Football Team Head Coach

UP Election 2022: Chunaav Pe Charcha | EJ In-depth: Who is the majority? The winner takes all system

Who is the real majority in India? We deep dive into the first past the post system! 

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:00
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected

      As election season inches closer, massive rallies with seas of people as far as the eye can see give a shining picture of our country as the world’s largest democracy. A fact that no party in power ever loses an opportunity to remind us - however as many say, the devil lies in the detail and a breakdown of India’s first past the post election system begs one to ask the question - what is the majority in India?

      India votes as per the first past the post system, also known as the system of winner takes all. Simply broken down, this method of voting means that each person of the electorate gets one vote and the candidates who gets the most votes wins - regardless of what their vote share is.

      This system works for a multiparty set up like India, where a simple majority is tough to reach. But that being said, as with all other systems - there are loopholes and shortcoming in this one too.

      One of the largest criticisms about FPTP is that it’s not representative in nature. Minorities, on account of never being able to beat out winning candidates in securing a greater number of votes, end up missing out on the opportunity of getting a seat at the decision-making table.

      Another criticism is that since it’s about the candidate who gets the greatest number of votes - the gap between the people who actually voted for you, versus the entire population is very wide. Let’s try to understand this using the example of Amethi constituency in Uttar Pradesh.

      In the 2017 Assembly election, Amethi had about 3 lakhs 34 thousand eligible electors. Of this only 1 lakh 87 thousand voted. That is a 56% voter turnout. Of this turn out - only 64,226 picked Garima Singh as their MLA - just 34% of the voters, and only 19% of the eligible voters. Despite the fact that a BJP MLA was not picked by 81% of the population in her constituency - we still call this the popular vote.

      Another facet of the FPTP is that there is no correlation between the vote shares and the seats secured. In 2017, the SP had a 21.8% vote share, and the BSP a 22.2% vote share, however despite the fact that BSP had more votes in terms of numbers, the SP secured 47 seats and the BSP only 19. This is because it’s not about the votes that are polled but the margins of victory and loss in each constituency.

      The numbers are a little confusing, but what are the other alternatives?

      Some have suggested a proportional representation system which is about allotting seats in the ratio of the vote share. If a party has 30% votes, give them 30% seats - it sounds simpler than it is. Many say that this is a logistical nightmare and can lead to severely unstable governments. In fact, arguing against the system of proportional representation, Dr.B R Ambedkar had said that reservation is a far better safeguard to the rights of minorities and marginalised groups.

      Let’s take a look at the numbers as they stand in UP today. In 2017, the BJP secured close to 40% of the total votes polled. The voter turnout was at an impressive 61.04% of the electorate. However, this number diminishes to 24.2% of the people who were actually eligible to vote. Another way of looking at it is 75.8% of eligible voters in the state didn’t support BJP.

      It has been the same story nationally since the start.


      No party, not even Congress under Jawaharlal Nehru, has won 50% vote share in any national elections, beginning 1951. The most a party has got is 48% under Rajiv Gandhi in 1984. The Congress won 404 of 514 Lok Sabha seats after Indira Gandhi's assassination.


      For four decades after Independence, Congress ruled the country with just over 40% voteshare.


      As the Congress domination waned and coalition era kicked in in late 80s and 90s, vote share of the main winning party plunged to 30%. 1996 to 2009, parties formed govts with less than 30% voteshare. The winning party's voteshare again crossed 30% when Narendra Modi-led BJP swept to power.

      So is there some confusion about ‘majority’ in our country? Yes

      There then remains only one way to lessen the gap in the numbers - and you know it already! Go vote! The biggest tool in our hands when it comes to making the assembly more representative in nature is to make sure that we exercise our sacred right to vote. There is enough time, so if you haven’t already - make sure to go and get your voter ID card made, and make these elections as democratic as possible!

      Uttar PradeshUP GovernmentUttar Pradesh NewsUP Election 2022UP Assembly Polls 2022UP 2022UP Assembly Election 2022

      ADVERTISEMENT

      Up Next

      UP Election 2022: Chunaav Pe Charcha | EJ In-depth: Who is the majority? The winner takes all system

      UP Election 2022: Chunaav Pe Charcha | EJ In-depth: Who is the majority? The winner takes all system

      Was this Shashi Tharoor's last election? Congress leader reveals

      Was this Shashi Tharoor's last election? Congress leader reveals

      What lies ahead for AIADMK after Lok Sabha debacle?

      What lies ahead for AIADMK after Lok Sabha debacle?

      Meet GenZ candidates set to become India’s youngest MPs

      Meet GenZ candidates set to become India’s youngest MPs

      Odisha's chief ministerial race: five BJP stalwarts in contention

      Odisha's chief ministerial race: five BJP stalwarts in contention

      Modi's swearing-in ceremony, India to invite top leaders of neighbouring countries: report

      Modi's swearing-in ceremony, India to invite top leaders of neighbouring countries: report

      ADVERTISEMENT

      editorji-whatsApp

      More videos

      Naidu and Kumar seek key cabinet posts in Modi's next term: report

      Naidu and Kumar seek key cabinet posts in Modi's next term: report

      What next for jailed Amritpal Singh, Engineer Rashid who have now become lawmakers?

      What next for jailed Amritpal Singh, Engineer Rashid who have now become lawmakers?

      Narendra Modi elected NDA leader, to be next PM

      Narendra Modi elected NDA leader, to be next PM

      Mallikarjun Kharge invites parties with 'shared values' to join INDIA bloc

      Mallikarjun Kharge invites parties with 'shared values' to join INDIA bloc

      INDIA bloc leaders hold meet at Mallikarjun Kharge residence

      INDIA bloc leaders hold meet at Mallikarjun Kharge residence

      President Murmu dissolves 17th Lok Sabha

      President Murmu dissolves 17th Lok Sabha

      Will top BJP allies stay in NDA or leave? Modi 3.0 hangs in the balance

      Will top BJP allies stay in NDA or leave? Modi 3.0 hangs in the balance

      NDA meet at PM Modi residence, discussion on forming govt

      NDA meet at PM Modi residence, discussion on forming govt

      KL Sharma wins Amethi, how Congress planned Rahul revenge

      KL Sharma wins Amethi, how Congress planned Rahul revenge

      Union Cabinet recommends dissolution of 17th Lok Sabha

      Union Cabinet recommends dissolution of 17th Lok Sabha

      Narendra Modi expected to take oath as PM on June 8: report

      Narendra Modi expected to take oath as PM on June 8: report

      Lok Sabha election results: Tejashwi Yadav pulled crowds in Bihar, but failed to turn them into votes

      Lok Sabha election results: Tejashwi Yadav pulled crowds in Bihar, but failed to turn them into votes

      JDU will give letter of support to NDA, PM Modi: KC Tyagi

      JDU will give letter of support to NDA, PM Modi: KC Tyagi

      INDIA bloc and NDA leaders in huddle after June 4 Lok Sabha result

      INDIA bloc and NDA leaders in huddle after June 4 Lok Sabha result

      Chandrababu Naidu breaks suspense over defection to INDIA bloc

      Chandrababu Naidu breaks suspense over defection to INDIA bloc

      Nitish Kumar, Chandrababu Naidu emerge as kingmakers as BJP short of majority

      Nitish Kumar, Chandrababu Naidu emerge as kingmakers as BJP short of majority

      BJP falls short of majority, Nitish Kumar to attend NDA meet in Delhi

      BJP falls short of majority, Nitish Kumar to attend NDA meet in Delhi

      Cycle rolls over BJP's Purvanchal fortress, comparison with 2019 result

      Cycle rolls over BJP's Purvanchal fortress, comparison with 2019 result

      Jailed Kashmiri leader beats Omar Abdullah, Sajad Lone to win Baramulla seat

      Jailed Kashmiri leader beats Omar Abdullah, Sajad Lone to win Baramulla seat

      PM Modi thanks Chandrababu Naidu, Nitish Kumar in victory speech | Lok Sabha election results

      PM Modi thanks Chandrababu Naidu, Nitish Kumar in victory speech | Lok Sabha election results

      For first time in 10 years, Congress opens account in Gujarat

      For first time in 10 years, Congress opens account in Gujarat

      How Rahul Gandhi set the Lok Sabha campaign narrative, and BJP followed

      How Rahul Gandhi set the Lok Sabha campaign narrative, and BJP followed

      Setback for BJP as Faizabad picks Samajwadi candidate Awadhesh Prasad

      Setback for BJP as Faizabad picks Samajwadi candidate Awadhesh Prasad

      BJP's Tamil Nadu star Annamalai's bleak ballot debut

      BJP's Tamil Nadu star Annamalai's bleak ballot debut

      Uttar Pradesh result establishes Akhilesh at centre stage, end of road for Mayawati

      Uttar Pradesh result establishes Akhilesh at centre stage, end of road for Mayawati

      When Modi loses, Adani stocks fall: Rahul Gandhi as BJP falls short of majority

      When Modi loses, Adani stocks fall: Rahul Gandhi as BJP falls short of majority

      Smriti Irani concedes defeat, thanks PM Modi, Yogi for letting her serve Amethi

      Smriti Irani concedes defeat, thanks PM Modi, Yogi for letting her serve Amethi

      Nation rejected politics of Modi, Shah: Rahul Gandhi in press conference

      Nation rejected politics of Modi, Shah: Rahul Gandhi in press conference

      London postgrad Iqra Hasan beats BJP in once communally charged Kairana

      London postgrad Iqra Hasan beats BJP in once communally charged Kairana

      Shyam Rangeela mimics PM Modi, 'calls' Nitish Kumar and Chandrababu Naidu in hilarious video

      Shyam Rangeela mimics PM Modi, 'calls' Nitish Kumar and Chandrababu Naidu in hilarious video

      'Real' Shiv Sena, NCP outperformed by Sharad, Uddhav in Maharashtra

      'Real' Shiv Sena, NCP outperformed by Sharad, Uddhav in Maharashtra

      BJP's Rajeev Chandrashekhar concedes defeat to Shashi Tharoor | Thiruvananthapuram LS seat

      BJP's Rajeev Chandrashekhar concedes defeat to Shashi Tharoor | Thiruvananthapuram LS seat

      NOTA gets record 2.18 lakh votes in Indore where Congress candidate withdrew

      NOTA gets record 2.18 lakh votes in Indore where Congress candidate withdrew

      Sharad Pawar denies talks with Nitish Kumar | Lok Sabha election results

      Sharad Pawar denies talks with Nitish Kumar | Lok Sabha election results

      Odisha assembly elections: BJP likely to dethrone Naveen Patnaik

      Odisha assembly elections: BJP likely to dethrone Naveen Patnaik

      Lok Sabha elections: INDIA bloc leading in 44 seats, BJP-led NDA in 35

      Lok Sabha elections: INDIA bloc leading in 44 seats, BJP-led NDA in 35

      Congress' Amethi pick KL Sharma reacts to potential win over BJP's Smriti Irani

      Congress' Amethi pick KL Sharma reacts to potential win over BJP's Smriti Irani

      Mamata Banerjee stays strong in her turf, outperforms BJP in West Bengal

      Mamata Banerjee stays strong in her turf, outperforms BJP in West Bengal

      BJP short of majority as per latest trends, NDA likely to cross 272

      BJP short of majority as per latest trends, NDA likely to cross 272

      BJP going to form govt for third time, says Kangana Ranaut

      BJP going to form govt for third time, says Kangana Ranaut

      Lok Sabha election results: Khalistani leader Amritpal Singh leads in Punjab

      Lok Sabha election results: Khalistani leader Amritpal Singh leads in Punjab

      Smriti Irani stares at defeat as KL Sharma takes massive lead in Amethi

      Smriti Irani stares at defeat as KL Sharma takes massive lead in Amethi

      BJP workers imitate shaving man's head to mock Somnath Bharti

      BJP workers imitate shaving man's head to mock Somnath Bharti

      'Not happy about Hassan result': JDS leader Kumaraswamy

      'Not happy about Hassan result': JDS leader Kumaraswamy

      Lok Sabha results LIVE: BJP set to lose heavily in Uttar Pradesh as SP-Congress leads in 42 seats 

      Lok Sabha results LIVE: BJP set to lose heavily in Uttar Pradesh as SP-Congress leads in 42 seats 

      BJP on verge of creating history in Kerala, Suresh Gopi poised to win from Thrissur

      BJP on verge of creating history in Kerala, Suresh Gopi poised to win from Thrissur

      Lok Sabha election 2024 results: counting of votes across 543 constituencies underway

      Lok Sabha election 2024 results: counting of votes across 543 constituencies underway

      Celebrations begin at TMC office in Kolkata | Watch

      Celebrations begin at TMC office in Kolkata | Watch

      Sanjay Raut bats for Rahul Gandhi as PM, says Congress may cross 150

      Sanjay Raut bats for Rahul Gandhi as PM, says Congress may cross 150

      Andhra Pradesh assembly polls result: Naidu's TDP well on its way to dethrone YSRCP

      Andhra Pradesh assembly polls result: Naidu's TDP well on its way to dethrone YSRCP

      'This is just trailer': Congress' Jairam Ramesh takes sly dig at BJP

      'This is just trailer': Congress' Jairam Ramesh takes sly dig at BJP

      BJP candidate Kangana Ranaut offer prayers on election result day

      BJP candidate Kangana Ranaut offer prayers on election result day

      Counting of votes for Andhra, Odisha assembly elections begins

      Counting of votes for Andhra, Odisha assembly elections begins

      These are early trends, won't celebrate prematurely: Supriya Shrinate

      These are early trends, won't celebrate prematurely: Supriya Shrinate

      We will comfortably form government: Congress candidate Vikramaditya Singh

      We will comfortably form government: Congress candidate Vikramaditya Singh

      Hoping exit poll proves right for J&K: NC leader Omar Abdullah

      Hoping exit poll proves right for J&K: NC leader Omar Abdullah

      Will work for all, whether they voted for me or not: Shashi Tharoor

      Will work for all, whether they voted for me or not: Shashi Tharoor

      Exit polls 2024: Congress likely to maintain lead in Punjab, no gain for AAP

      Exit polls 2024: Congress likely to maintain lead in Punjab, no gain for AAP

      Today is last day of dictatorship: AAP leader Gopal Rai

      Today is last day of dictatorship: AAP leader Gopal Rai

      Ram Rajya will continue: BJP Gorakhpur candidate Ravi Kishan

      Ram Rajya will continue: BJP Gorakhpur candidate Ravi Kishan

      'Teesri baar Modi sarkaar': BJP's Bansuri Swaraj confident of win

      'Teesri baar Modi sarkaar': BJP's Bansuri Swaraj confident of win

      'Modi Ka Pariwar' in hearts of all Indians: K Madhavi Latha

      'Modi Ka Pariwar' in hearts of all Indians: K Madhavi Latha

      5 injured in crude bomb blast in West Bengal's South 24 Parganas

      5 injured in crude bomb blast in West Bengal's South 24 Parganas

      EC 'outrightly' rejects Jairam Ramesh's request for extra time to back claims

      EC 'outrightly' rejects Jairam Ramesh's request for extra time to back claims

      'Cannot spread a rumour..': CEC responds to Congress' Jairam Ramesh's allegations

      'Cannot spread a rumour..': CEC responds to Congress' Jairam Ramesh's allegations

      Chief Election Commissioner Rajiv Kumar reacts to 'Laapata gentlemen' memes | Watch

      Chief Election Commissioner Rajiv Kumar reacts to 'Laapata gentlemen' memes | Watch

      BJP plans mega event to mark 2024 Lok Sabha election victory: report

      BJP plans mega event to mark 2024 Lok Sabha election victory: report

      'Just wait and see': Sonia Gandhi on INDIA bloc's chances of winning 2024 Lok Sabha election

      'Just wait and see': Sonia Gandhi on INDIA bloc's chances of winning 2024 Lok Sabha election

      In rare move, EC to hold presser day before counting of votes

      In rare move, EC to hold presser day before counting of votes

      Kejriwal lists 'theories' behind exit poll: 'bid to prevent mutiny in BJP'

      Kejriwal lists 'theories' behind exit poll: 'bid to prevent mutiny in BJP'

      Count postal ballots before declaring EVM results: INDIA bloc to EC

      Count postal ballots before declaring EVM results: INDIA bloc to EC

      Sandeshkhali sees post-poll violence, Guv writes to Mamata

      Sandeshkhali sees post-poll violence, Guv writes to Mamata

      Arvind Kejriwal returns to Tihar Jail as interim bail ends

      Arvind Kejriwal returns to Tihar Jail as interim bail ends

      SKM sweeps assembly elections in Sikkim, wins 31 of 32 seats

      SKM sweeps assembly elections in Sikkim, wins 31 of 32 seats

      BJP wins Arunachal Pradesh assembly elections for third straight time

      BJP wins Arunachal Pradesh assembly elections for third straight time

      Watch: Rahul Gandhi slams exit polls, predicts these many seats for INDIA bloc

      Watch: Rahul Gandhi slams exit polls, predicts these many seats for INDIA bloc

      'Will shave off my head if...': AAP's Somnath Bharti's claim on exit polls predicting NDA win

      'Will shave off my head if...': AAP's Somnath Bharti's claim on exit polls predicting NDA win

      Sikkim-Arunachal Pradesh assembly polls: counting for votes begin amid heavy security

      Sikkim-Arunachal Pradesh assembly polls: counting for votes begin amid heavy security

      Lok Sabha elections 2024 exit polls: poll of polls predict big victory for Modi-led NDA

      Lok Sabha elections 2024 exit polls: poll of polls predict big victory for Modi-led NDA

      Pawan Khera calls exit poll 'source of entertainment', slams PM Modi for his tweet

      Pawan Khera calls exit poll 'source of entertainment', slams PM Modi for his tweet

      'Delusional politics': Hardeep Singh Puri slams Congress' 295 seats claim

      'Delusional politics': Hardeep Singh Puri slams Congress' 295 seats claim

      'Sarkari exit poll': Supriya Shrinate slams exit poll surveys predicting Modi sweep

      'Sarkari exit poll': Supriya Shrinate slams exit poll surveys predicting Modi sweep

      INDIA bloc will win at least 295 seats, Kharge asserts after opposition meet

      INDIA bloc will win at least 295 seats, Kharge asserts after opposition meet

      PM Modi ends his 45-hour long meditation, visits Tamil poet's statue

      PM Modi ends his 45-hour long meditation, visits Tamil poet's statue

      INDIA bloc meet underway to discuss strategy for counting day | Lok Sabha elections

      INDIA bloc meet underway to discuss strategy for counting day | Lok Sabha elections

      BJP leader sends ambulance for Kejriwal, says CM creating drama over health

      BJP leader sends ambulance for Kejriwal, says CM creating drama over health

      Lok Sabha polls final phase: voter turnout at 40.09% till 1 pm

      Lok Sabha polls final phase: voter turnout at 40.09% till 1 pm

      Pawan Khera responds to Amit Shah's 'denial mode' dig at party for skipping exit poll debates

      Pawan Khera responds to Amit Shah's 'denial mode' dig at party for skipping exit poll debates

      Sporadic incidents of violence mar final phase of voting in Bengal

      Sporadic incidents of violence mar final phase of voting in Bengal

      Watch: election underway at world's highest polling station- Tashigang

      Watch: election underway at world's highest polling station- Tashigang

      Seventh phase of voting: EVMs, VVPAT looted in West Bengal, thrown into pond

      Seventh phase of voting: EVMs, VVPAT looted in West Bengal, thrown into pond

      Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.