News that fits you

Highlights

  • SC allows 30-week pregnancy termination for 17-year-old minor
  • Bench stresses reproductive autonomy; no woman can be forced to continue pregnancy
  • Warns against unsafe procedures if termination is denied

Latest news

Redmi Turbo 5 Review: Big Battery, Fast Gaming, Great Value

Redmi Turbo 5 Review: Big Battery, Fast Gaming, Great Value

CBIC Chairman highlights customs' role in supporting semiconductor, pharma and energy sectors

CBIC Chairman highlights customs' role in supporting semiconductor, pharma and energy sectors

Vibez Manor Wins 'Excellence in Farmland Project' at ET NOW Realty Conclave & Awards 2026

Vibez Manor Wins 'Excellence in Farmland Project' at ET NOW Realty Conclave & Awards 2026

Chandukaka Saraf Jewels Launches 'RITI 2.0' Lightweight Gold Collection Ahead of Key Jewellery Buying Season

Chandukaka Saraf Jewels Launches 'RITI 2.0' Lightweight Gold Collection Ahead of Key Jewellery Buying Season

Crude may stay capped near $80 if US-Iran truce holds, Hormuz fully reopens: Expert

Crude may stay capped near $80 if US-Iran truce holds, Hormuz fully reopens: Expert

Fahadh Faasil to lead two Malayalam films, teams up with Jacob Babu and Panorama Studios

Fahadh Faasil to lead two Malayalam films, teams up with Jacob Babu and Panorama Studios

Mumbai Police to Receive Monsoon Protection Across Seven Police Stations: Lions Club of Mumbai SOL and RASYS Unite in Tribute to Frontline Heroes

Mumbai Police to Receive Monsoon Protection Across Seven Police Stations: Lions Club of Mumbai SOL and RASYS Unite in Tribute to Frontline Heroes

India-Monaco set to deepen economic ties across key sectors: Piyush Goyal

India-Monaco set to deepen economic ties across key sectors: Piyush Goyal

'Can't compel woman to complete pregnancy': SC allows minor to terminate 30-week pregnancy

The Supreme Court directed Mumbai’s JJ Hospital to terminate a 30-week pregnancy of a minor, ruling that no woman, including a minor, can be compelled to continue an unwanted pregnancy.

Updated: Sep 02, 2022 10:53
|

PTI

'Can't compel woman to complete pregnancy': SC allows minor to terminate 30-week pregnancy

Directing medical termination of a 30-week pregnancy of a 17-year-old girl, the Supreme Court on Friday said that courts cannot compel a woman, much less a minor, to continue a pregnancy.

A bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan noted that the girl had become pregnant while being in a relationship with a neighbourhood boy and sought to medically terminate her pregnancy.

The bench asked Mumbai's JJ Hospital to undertake the medical termination of the pregnancy of the minor while ensuring that all necessary medical safeguards are followed.

The bench observed that the court had considered the fact that the right of the minor child to continue the pregnancy, which, on the face of it, was "illegitimate" as she herself was a minor and was facing the pregnancy due to an unfortunate situation arising from a relationship.

It said the issue was not whether the relationship was consensual or the result of sexual assault.

"What has to be considered in the instant case is the right of the minor child to continue a pregnancy which is ex-facie illegitimate in as much as she is a minor and has to face this unfortunate situation of having the pregnancy owing to a relationship that she had. The issue is not whether the relationship was consensual or whether it was a case of sexual assault. Ultimately, the fact is that the child to be is not legitimate and secondly, the mother to be of the child does not want to bear the child," the bench said.

The top court noted the report of the medical board of the hospital that there was no threat to the life of the child and the mother if allowed to give birth after full term.

"If the interest of the mother is to be taken note of, then her reproductive autonomy must be given sufficient emphasis. The court cannot compel any woman, much less a minor child, to complete her pregnancy if she is otherwise not intending to do so," the bench said.

During the hearing, Justice Nagarathna noted the difficult questions of morality and legal questions which the court has to deal with and said if the court does not deal with the medical termination, then people will visit quacks and illegal medical establishments and that will not be safe for them.

It said that while the birth of a child ultimately results in a life, the decisive factor in the present case was the clear and consistent unwillingness of the minor to continue the pregnancy.

"It is also difficult for us but there is no other way. Should we compel her to give birth to a child? Because the child which will be born is also ultimately going to be a life.

"There is another question; if she can terminate the pregnancy at 24 weeks, then why not at 30 weeks? Ultimately, she doesn't want to continue the pregnancy. Bottom line is she doesn't want to give birth, that is the difficulty," the bench observed.

It added that sometimes it takes time to decide whether to terminate the pregnancy or not.

"There are so many cases where termination takes place beyond what's stipulated under the MTP (Medical Termination of Pregnancy) Act (1971). And doctors say we won't do it.

"Where will such people go? To quacks and unauthorised doctors. That will be dangerous," it said.

Counsel appearing for the Maharashtra government submitted that according to medical reports, even if the child is allowed to be born today, the child is going to be alive and one of the views of the high court was that the baby can be given to an orphanage if the mother does not want to keep it.

The top court said it will release the operating part of the order for the benefit of the hospital and the detailed order will follow.

ADVERTISEMENT

Up Next

'Can't compel woman to complete pregnancy': SC allows minor to terminate 30-week pregnancy

'Can't compel woman to complete pregnancy': SC allows minor to terminate 30-week pregnancy

SC seeks responses of Centre, States on plea for use of Aadhaar as identity proof only

SC seeks responses of Centre, States on plea for use of Aadhaar as identity proof only

Abhijeet Dipke slapped during Jaipur protest; 'intimidation tactics', alleges CJP founder

Abhijeet Dipke slapped during Jaipur protest; 'intimidation tactics', alleges CJP founder

3 vessels with Indian seafarers attacked by US Navy; India says these strikes must stop

3 vessels with Indian seafarers attacked by US Navy; India says these strikes must stop

Three missing Indian seafarers onboard MT Settebello confirmed dead: Sonowal

Three missing Indian seafarers onboard MT Settebello confirmed dead: Sonowal

Rs 370 biryani remark: NCW summons More, Jangra over Gurugram comedy show

Rs 370 biryani remark: NCW summons More, Jangra over Gurugram comedy show

ADVERTISEMENT

editorji-whatsApp

More videos

'Choose between Abhishek and me': Kalyan issues ultimatum to Mamata amid TMC imbroglio

'Choose between Abhishek and me': Kalyan issues ultimatum to Mamata amid TMC imbroglio

NDA leaders felicitate Modi as he becomes longest-serving elected PM

NDA leaders felicitate Modi as he becomes longest-serving elected PM

CJP to launch nationwide protest on Thursday, warns of indefinite sit-in

CJP to launch nationwide protest on Thursday, warns of indefinite sit-in

Rebel Trinamool leader Ritabrata claims dissident camp is ‘real TMC’, rules out merger with Congress

Rebel Trinamool leader Ritabrata claims dissident camp is ‘real TMC’, rules out merger with Congress

Dharmendra Pradhan reviews re-NEET preparations, assures students of error-free exam

Dharmendra Pradhan reviews re-NEET preparations, assures students of error-free exam

PM Modi to undertake visit to France, Slovakia; to attend G7 Summit

PM Modi to undertake visit to France, Slovakia; to attend G7 Summit

Rs 6,800-cr Zojila tunnel project in J-K achieves breakthrough in excavation work

Rs 6,800-cr Zojila tunnel project in J-K achieves breakthrough in excavation work

India urges global community to hold Pakistan accountable after deadly PoK violence

India urges global community to hold Pakistan accountable after deadly PoK violence

Rajya Sabha Elections: MP Congress candidate Meenakshi Natarajan's nomination rejected during scrutiny

Rajya Sabha Elections: MP Congress candidate Meenakshi Natarajan's nomination rejected during scrutiny

TMC rebellion spreads from assembly to Parliament, breakaway camp claims support of 20 MPs

TMC rebellion spreads from assembly to Parliament, breakaway camp claims support of 20 MPs

Categories

Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.