Highlights

  • Court grants bail to Ratan Lal
  • FIR against Lal for Gyanvapi 'Shivling' post
  • Lal was arrested Friday

Latest news

Never thought about myself but only the team: Deepak Hooda

Never thought about myself but only the team: Deepak Hooda

Udaipur murder case: NIA to take over probe, international links under scanner

Udaipur murder case: NIA to take over probe, international links under scanner

As rebel Sena MLAs leave Guwahati, a donation for Assam flood relief

As rebel Sena MLAs leave Guwahati, a donation for Assam flood relief

'Shamshera' first song 'Ji Huzoor' out: Ranbir Kapoor will surely make you put on your dancing shoes

'Shamshera' first song 'Ji Huzoor' out: Ranbir Kapoor will surely make you put on your dancing shoes

Suriya, Kajol and Reema Kagti invited to join Oscar committee

Suriya, Kajol and Reema Kagti invited to join Oscar committee

'Failed attempt at satire': DU prof arrested for objectionable post on Gyanvapi 'Shivling' gets bail

The court directed Ratan Lal to refrain from posting on social media and giving interviews regarding the controversy which landed him in jail.  

A city court on Saturday granted bail to Delhi University Associate Professor Ratan Lal, arrested for alleged objectionable remarks on social media related to claims of a 'Shivling' at Varanasi's Gyanvapi mosque, saying his post, though reprehensible, does not indicate an attempt to promote hatred between communities.

The court directed Lal to “strictly refrain from posting any social media posts or interviews regarding the controversy which resulted in the present FIR”, while allowing his release on furnishing a personal bond of Rs 50,000 and one surety of the like amount.

Lal was arrested on Friday night by the Delhi Police under Indian Penal Code sections 153A (promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, residence, language, etc., and doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony) and 295A (deliberate act to outrage religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion).

WATCH | Gyanvapi mosque row: DU professor arrested after complaint over 'objectionable' Shivling post

Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Siddhartha Malik said that the feeling of hurt felt by an individual cannot represent the entire group or community and any such complaint regarding hurt feeling has to be seen in its context, considering the entire spectrum of facts and circumstances.

The court said that the Indian civilisation is one of the oldest in the world and is known to be tolerant and accepting of all religions, adding that the presence or absence of intention to create animosity by words was subjective in nature as was the perception of the recipient who reads or hears a statement.

“India is a country of more than 130 crore people and any subject can have 130 crore different views and perceptions,” it said.

The court noted that the social media post of Lal, who teaches History at the Hindu College, may appear to be a failed attempt at satire regarding a controversial subject that has backfired, resulting in the FlR.

It further noted that the accused, in personal life, was a proud follower of the Hindu religion.

“For another person, the same post can appear to be shameful but may not incite the feeling of hatred towards another community. Similarly, different persons may consider the post differently without being enraged and may in fact feel sorry for the accused to have made an unwanted comment without considering the repercussions,” the court said.

It noted that it was true that the accused did an act that was avoidable considering the sensibilities of persons around the him, and the public at large.

“However, the post, though reprehensible, does not indicate an attempt to promote hatred between communities,” the court said.

The judge, meanwhile, said that the anxiety of police could be understood as the police are tasked to maintain peace and order and at the slightest hint of unrest would come into action to prevent the situation from going out of hand.

However, the court has to employ higher standards while considering the need to send a person to custody, it said.

“The present accused is a person of good repute with no criminal antecedent and there is no likelihood of the accused fleeing the course of law.

"In view of the aforesaid, the court sees no need to send the accused to judicial custody,” the judge said.

During the argument, the defence counsel told the court that the accused had no intention to hurt the religious feeling of any person or group and he had simply made a light-hearted comment on a matter which was still pending before various courts in the country.

The prosecution opposed the bail plea and sought his judicial custody, saying that the Facebook post was “clearly meant to incite hatred between religious groups”.

It said the accused had given various interviews after the post where he has again made the same derogatory remarks.

An FIR was lodged against Lal on Tuesday night based on a complaint filed by a Delhi-based lawyer.

In his complaint, advocate Vineet Jindal alleged that Lal had recently shared a "derogatory, inciting and provocating tweet on the Shivling".

Left-affiliated All India Students Association (AISA) activists on Saturday staged a protest outside Delhi University's Arts Faculty against the arrest of Lal.

Up Next

'Failed attempt at satire': DU prof arrested for objectionable post on Gyanvapi 'Shivling' gets bail

'Failed attempt at satire': DU prof arrested for objectionable post on Gyanvapi 'Shivling' gets bail

As rebel Sena MLAs leave Guwahati, a donation for Assam flood relief

As rebel Sena MLAs leave Guwahati, a donation for Assam flood relief

Maharashtra Floor Test: Aghadi govt moves Supreme Court, hearing at 5pm

Maharashtra Floor Test: Aghadi govt moves Supreme Court, hearing at 5pm

Covid vaccine Covovax gets nod for children aged 7-11 from Indian regulator: reports

Covid vaccine Covovax gets nod for children aged 7-11 from Indian regulator: reports

Bihar: Lightning strikes and kills 16 in last 24 hours; IMD issues red alert for today

Bihar: Lightning strikes and kills 16 in last 24 hours; IMD issues red alert for today

Uddhav Thackeray set to face floor test Thursday, Shinde camp to be back in Mumbai

Uddhav Thackeray set to face floor test Thursday, Shinde camp to be back in Mumbai

More videos

Udaipur tailor received threats, police officer suspended for negligence: top cop

Udaipur tailor received threats, police officer suspended for negligence: top cop

Journalists shouldn't be jailed for what they write, tweet and say: UN spokesperson

Journalists shouldn't be jailed for what they write, tweet and say: UN spokesperson

Pakistan jails 'dead' terrorist to evade FATF 'black list': Lashkar's 26/11 plotter Sajid Mir behind bars

Pakistan jails 'dead' terrorist to evade FATF 'black list': Lashkar's 26/11 plotter Sajid Mir behind bars

WATCH | BJP leader Devendra Fadnavis meets Maharashtra governor, asks for floor test

WATCH | BJP leader Devendra Fadnavis meets Maharashtra governor, asks for floor test

Udaipur killing: Centre rushes NIA team, internet suspended across Rajasthan

Udaipur killing: Centre rushes NIA team, internet suspended across Rajasthan

Man murdered in Udaipur: internet suspended, mass gathering banned in entire Rajasthan

Man murdered in Udaipur: internet suspended, mass gathering banned in entire Rajasthan

Udaipur Murder Case: 2 arrested for murdering man in Udaipur, prohibitory orders imposed

Udaipur Murder Case: 2 arrested for murdering man in Udaipur, prohibitory orders imposed

Udaipur man's murder sparks tensions, internet shut

Udaipur man's murder sparks tensions, internet shut

Fact-checker journalist Mohd Zubair sent to police custody for 4 more days

Fact-checker journalist Mohd Zubair sent to police custody for 4 more days

Single use plastic faces complete ban from July 1, Straws to earbuds off the racks

Single use plastic faces complete ban from July 1, Straws to earbuds off the racks

Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.