Highlights

  • Speculation over new Twitter rules after Elon Musk's takeover
  • Elon Musk has claimed to be a 'free speech absolutist'
  • Twitter has been facing misinformation, hate speech challenges

Latest news

WATCH: Indian Coast Guard rescues crew from sinking ship in Arabian sea

WATCH: Indian Coast Guard rescues crew from sinking ship in Arabian sea

India vs England 1st T20I Preview, Playing XI Prediction, live toss time, telecast and streaming details

India vs England 1st T20I Preview, Playing XI Prediction, live toss time, telecast and streaming details

'Malfunctions not unique but will be doubly careful': SpiceJet boss Ajay Singh

'Malfunctions not unique but will be doubly careful': SpiceJet boss Ajay Singh

Why Swiggy 'cannot hold its horses' while delivering your food

Why Swiggy 'cannot hold its horses' while delivering your food

'Ponniyin Selvan': Aishwarya Rai Bachchan looks magnificent as Nandini in Mani Ratnam's film poster

'Ponniyin Selvan': Aishwarya Rai Bachchan looks magnificent as Nandini in Mani Ratnam's film poster

Would Elon Musk’s plans for Twitter make its misinformation problems worse?

The big question now is how far Musk, who describes himself as a “free-speech absolutist,” wants to ratchet back these systems — and whether users and advertisers will stick around if he does.

Elon Musk, the world’s richest person, acquired Twitter in a US$44 billion deal on April 25, 2022, 11 days after announcing his bid for the company.

Twitter announced that the public company will become privately held after the acquisition is complete.

In a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission for his initial bid for the company, Musk stated, “I invested in Twitter as I believe in its potential to be the platform for free speech around the globe, and I believe free speech is a societal imperative for a functioning democracy.” As a researcher of social media platforms, I find that Musk’s ownership of Twitter and his stated reasons for buying the company raise important issues. Those issues stem from the nature of the social media platform and what sets it apart from others.

What makes Twitter unique Twitter occupies a unique niche. Its short chunks of text and threading foster real-time conversations among thousands of people, which makes it popular with celebrities, media personalities and politicians alike.

Social media analysts talk about the half-life of content on a platform, meaning the time it takes for a piece of content to reach 50% of its total lifetime engagement, usually measured in number of views or popularity based metrics.

The average half life of a tweet is about 20 minutes, compared to five hours for Facebook posts, 20 hours for Instagram posts, 24 hours for LinkedIn posts and 20 days for YouTube videos.

WATCH: Red Bull plane swap crash: USA's FAA had denied exemption request, say reports, after stunt goes wrong

The much shorter half life illustrates the central role Twitter has come to occupy in driving real-time conversations as events unfold.

Twitter’s ability to shape real-time discourse, as well as the ease with which data, including geo-tagged data, can be gathered from Twitter has made it a gold mine for researchers to analyse a variety of societal phenomena, ranging from public health to politics.

Twitter data has been used to predict asthma-related emergency department visits, measure public epidemic awareness, and model wildfire smoke dispersion.

Tweets that are part of a conversation are shown in chronological order, and, even though much of a tweet’s engagement is frontloaded, the Twitter archive provides instant and complete access to every public Tweet.

This positions Twitter as a historical chronicler of record and a de facto fact checker.

Changes on Musk’s mind A crucial issue is how Musk’s ownership of Twitter, and private control of social media platforms generally, affect the broader public well-being. In a series of deleted tweets, Musk made several suggestions about how to change Twitter, including adding an edit button for tweets and granting automatic verification marks to premium users.

There is no experimental evidence about how an edit button would change information transmission on Twitter. However, it’s possible to extrapolate from previous research that analyzed deleted tweets.

There are numerous ways to retrieve deleted tweets, which allows researchers to study them.

While some studies show significant personality differences between users who delete their tweets and those who don’t, these findings suggest that deleting tweets is a way for people to manage their online identities.

Analysing deleting behaviour can also yield valuable clues about online credibility and disinformation.

Similarly, if Twitter adds an edit button, analysing the patterns of editing behaviour could provide insights into Twitter users’ motivations and how they present themselves.

Studies of bot-generated activity on Twitter have concluded that nearly half of accounts tweeting about COVID-19 are likely bots.

Given partisanship and political polarization in online spaces, allowing users – whether they are automated bots or actual people – the option to edit their tweets could become another weapon in the disinformation arsenal used by bots and propagandists.

Editing tweets could allow users to selectively distort what they said, or deny making inflammatory remarks, which could complicate efforts to trace misinformation.

Musk has also indicated his intention to combat twitter bots, or automated accounts that post rapidly and repeatedly in the guise of people. He has called for authenticating users as real human beings.

Given challenges such as doxxing and other malicious personal harms online, it’s important for user authentication methods to preserve privacy. This is particularly important for activists, dissidents and whistleblowers who face threats for their online activities. Mechanisms such as decentralised protocols can enable authentication without sacrificing anonymity.

Twitter’s content moderation and revenue model To understand Musk’s motivations and what lies next for social media platforms such as Twitter, it’s important to consider the gargantuan – and opaque – online advertising ecosystem involving multiple technologies wielded by ad networks, social media companies and publishers. Advertising is the primary revenue source for Twitter.

Musk’s vision is to generate revenue for Twitter from subscriptions rather than advertising.

Without having to worry about attracting and retaining advertisers, Twitter would have less pressure to focus on content moderation.

This could make Twitter a sort of freewheeling opinion site for paying subscribers.

In contrast, until now Twitter has been aggressive in using content moderation in its attempts to address disinformation.

Musk’s description of a platform free from content moderation issues is troubling in light of the algorithmic harms caused by social media platforms. Research has shown a host of these harms, such as algorithms that assign gender to users, potential inaccuracies and biases in algorithms used to glean information from these platforms, and the impact on those looking for health information online.

Testimony by Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen and recent regulatory efforts such as the online safety bill unveiled in the U.K. show there is broad public concern about the role played by technology platforms in shaping popular discourse and public opinion.

Musk’s acquisition of Twitter highlights a whole host of regulatory concerns.

Because of Musk’s other businesses, Twitter’s ability to influence public opinion in the sensitive industries of aviation and the automobile industry automatically creates a conflict of interest, not to mention affects the disclosure of material information necessary for shareholders.

Musk has already been accused of delaying disclosure of his ownership stake in Twitter.

Twitter’s own algorithmic bias bounty challenge concluded that there needs to be a community-led approach to build better algorithms.

A very creative exercise developed by the MIT Media Lab asks middle schoolers to re-imagine the YouTube platform with ethics in mind. Perhaps it’s time to ask Musk to do the same with Twitter.

Up Next

Would Elon Musk’s plans for Twitter make its misinformation problems worse?

Would Elon Musk’s plans for Twitter make its misinformation problems worse?

Palestinian rivals President Abbas, Hamas chief hold rare meet in Algeria

Palestinian rivals President Abbas, Hamas chief hold rare meet in Algeria

India proposes G-20 in Ladakh despite China objecting to J&K as venue

India proposes G-20 in Ladakh despite China objecting to J&K as venue

Boris Johnson fights for his future: what led to spate of resignations | Explained

Boris Johnson fights for his future: what led to spate of resignations | Explained

From scoring highest to lowest: Bengaluru's 'liveability' dilemma

From scoring highest to lowest: Bengaluru's 'liveability' dilemma

Boris Johnson cabinet crisis: two more ministers, ministerial aide resign

Boris Johnson cabinet crisis: two more ministers, ministerial aide resign

More videos

Otters chill out in bucket of ice cubes: the cutest video you will see on internet today

Otters chill out in bucket of ice cubes: the cutest video you will see on internet today

Sri Lankans return to cooking with firewood as crisis deepens

Sri Lankans return to cooking with firewood as crisis deepens

This country moves to make work-from-home a legal right

This country moves to make work-from-home a legal right

Canada News : more than 100 Sikh guards lose job over clean shave rule

Canada News : more than 100 Sikh guards lose job over clean shave rule

Canadian MP on Goddess Kaali poster row: anti-Hindu groups have joined forces

Canadian MP on Goddess Kaali poster row: anti-Hindu groups have joined forces

Why Canada is throwing 13.6 million doses of Covid-19 vaccine

Why Canada is throwing 13.6 million doses of Covid-19 vaccine

Gunman fired more than 70 rounds at Chicago's July 4 parade: police

Gunman fired more than 70 rounds at Chicago's July 4 parade: police

Boris Johnson govt in trouble, finance minister Rishi Sunak & health secretary Sajid Javid resign

Boris Johnson govt in trouble, finance minister Rishi Sunak & health secretary Sajid Javid resign

China using factories in USA to spy? $2.6 million land deal near Air Force drone base sparks worry

China using factories in USA to spy? $2.6 million land deal near Air Force drone base sparks worry

Taliban founder Mullah Umar's car dug up after 21 years. See pictures

Taliban founder Mullah Umar's car dug up after 21 years. See pictures

Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.