Highlights

  • Police briefings should not lead to media trial: SC
  • Premature disclosure by police triggers media trial: SC
  • Prepare manual for police in 3 months: SC to Centre

Latest news

Pakistani official declared persona non grata, told to leave India within 24 hours

Pakistani official declared persona non grata, told to leave India within 24 hours

CBSE class 10 results: Over 93 pc students pass exam, girls outperform boys by over 2 pc points

CBSE class 10 results: Over 93 pc students pass exam, girls outperform boys by over 2 pc points

3 Terrorists Killed In Encounter In Jammu And Kashmir's Shopian

3 Terrorists Killed In Encounter In Jammu And Kashmir's Shopian

Uttarakhand CM Dhami visits Latu Devta shrine on Buddha Purnima, prays for state's welfare

Uttarakhand CM Dhami visits Latu Devta shrine on Buddha Purnima, prays for state's welfare

Uttarakhand CM Dhami lauds PM Modi’s strong stance on countering terrorism

Uttarakhand CM Dhami lauds PM Modi’s strong stance on countering terrorism

Uttarakhand ranks 2nd in financial performance among small states

Uttarakhand ranks 2nd in financial performance among small states

Operation Sindoor: Need heightened vigilance against 'urban naxals', says UP CM

Operation Sindoor: Need heightened vigilance against 'urban naxals', says UP CM

UP govt says 'neutralised' 230 criminals, dismantled terrorist sleeper cells in 8 years

UP govt says 'neutralised' 230 criminals, dismantled terrorist sleeper cells in 8 years

Police disclosure must not result in media trial: SC

The Supreme Court said there is an urgent need for a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) about how journalists should be briefed by police in criminal cases.

Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:00
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected


      A media trial may result in "deflection of cause of justice", the Supreme Court observed on Wednesday and directed the union home ministry to prepare within three months a comprehensive manual on how police should brief journalists about criminal cases.

      The top court said there is an urgent need for a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) about how journalists should be briefed as there has been an upsurge in reporting on criminal offences in print, electronic and social media since the last guidelines on the subject were issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) in 2010.

      A bench headed by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud said a delicate balance has to be maintained between the media's fundamental right to free speech and expression, the right of the accused to fair investigation, and the privacy of the victim.

      The top court also asked the Directors General of Police (DGP) of all states to submit their suggestions to the MHA within a month on how to go about preparing the manual.

      "All DGPs, in a month, should communicate to Ministry of Home Affairs, their suggestions for guidelines...National Human Rights Commission's suggestions may also be taken," the bench, also comprising Justices PS Narasimha and Manoj Misra, said.

      The SC said any disclosure by police at a "premature stage", when the investigation is on, triggers a media trial that affects administration of justice since it could also influence the judge conducting the trial.

      The top court said the nature of disclosure by police, in the absence of an SOP, cannot be uniform as it would depend on the nature of crime and participating stakeholders including victims, witnesses and accused. The age and gender of the victim and accused also have a significant bearing on the disclosure, it said.

      "Media reporting in matters involving commission of crimes involves several aspects of public interest. At a basic level, the fundamental right to free speech and expression is directly both in terms of rights of media to portray and disseminate news, views and information and the right of the viewing public and readers to receive a diversity of opinions.

      "There can be no gainsaying in the fact that the media in terms of its right to speech and expression and consumers have a right to receive fair and unbiased information. Criminal offences and investigation by law enforcement machinery involves significant elements of public interest bearing upon the right to inform as well as the right to know," the bench said.

      The apex court said there are competing considerations involving the accused and the victim which needed to be considered as they have immense significance.

      "At one level the accused whose conduct is under investigation is entitled to a fair and unbiased investigation by the police. At the stage of trial, every accused is entitled to assumption of innocence and hence media reportage in a manner which implicates the culpability of a person who is under investigation is liable to seriously impinge upon the reputation and personal dignity of the individual under investigation," the bench said.

      Maintaining that biased reporting gives rise to public suspicion that the person under investigation is, in fact, guilty, the top court said media reportage also impinges upon the right of the victims or survivors of the crime.

      "There can be no denying the fact that disclosure of official version of the investigation would ensure against speculation on crime reporting. Thus, there is a need to have a uniform policy which can be adopted for notifying nodal officers who would be available to share the stage of investigation.

      "....The guidelines must ensure that disclosure does not result in a media trial so as to allow prejudging of the accused. Media trials are liable to result in deflection of cause of justice by impacting upon the evidence which should be adduced and its assessment by adjudicating authorities," the bench said.

      Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, who was appointed the amicus curiae in the matter to help the court, said while the press cannot be restrained from reporting, the sources of information, which are often government entities, can be regulated.

      He cited the 2008 Aarushi Talwar murder case where multiple police officials gave different versions of the incident to media. Aarushi Talwar, 13, and Hemraj, an elderly male domestic help, were found murdered in a Noida home, and the needle of suspicion pointed at the girl's parents.

      The senior lawyer submitted before the court the guidelines to be considered for the purpose of framing a comprehensive manual.

      The top court was hearing a petition about the modalities followed by police while briefing the media about criminal cases under investigation.

      Also Watch: 'Will you send police to arrest your minister?': Congress asks Assam CM

      ADVERTISEMENT

      Up Next

      Police disclosure must not result in media trial: SC

      Police disclosure must not result in media trial: SC

      Pakistani official declared persona non grata, told to leave India within 24 hours

      Pakistani official declared persona non grata, told to leave India within 24 hours

      CBSE class 10 results: Over 93 pc students pass exam, girls outperform boys by over 2 pc points

      CBSE class 10 results: Over 93 pc students pass exam, girls outperform boys by over 2 pc points

      Uttarakhand CM Dhami visits Latu Devta shrine on Buddha Purnima, prays for state's welfare

      Uttarakhand CM Dhami visits Latu Devta shrine on Buddha Purnima, prays for state's welfare

      Uttarakhand CM Dhami lauds PM Modi’s strong stance on countering terrorism

      Uttarakhand CM Dhami lauds PM Modi’s strong stance on countering terrorism

      Uttarakhand ranks 2nd in financial performance among small states

      Uttarakhand ranks 2nd in financial performance among small states

      ADVERTISEMENT

      editorji-whatsApp

      More videos

      At least 14 die after drinking spurious liquor in Punjab; 7 held

      At least 14 die after drinking spurious liquor in Punjab; 7 held

      Operation Sindoor: Need heightened vigilance against 'urban naxals', says UP CM

      Operation Sindoor: Need heightened vigilance against 'urban naxals', says UP CM

      UP govt says 'neutralised' 230 criminals, dismantled terrorist sleeper cells in 8 years

      UP govt says 'neutralised' 230 criminals, dismantled terrorist sleeper cells in 8 years

      PM Modi travels to Adampur air base, interacts with soldiers

      PM Modi travels to Adampur air base, interacts with soldiers

      UP govt drafts building construction byelaws, aims to provide fillip to urban development

      UP govt drafts building construction byelaws, aims to provide fillip to urban development

      CM Adityanath inspects health infrastructure projects underway at BHU campus

      CM Adityanath inspects health infrastructure projects underway at BHU campus

      Pollachi sexual assault case: TN Mahila court holds 9 arrested men as guilty

      Pollachi sexual assault case: TN Mahila court holds 9 arrested men as guilty

      CBSE class 12 results declared, girls outshine boys again

      CBSE class 12 results declared, girls outshine boys again

      PM Modi shaped new doctrine for India, issued warning to Pak-sponsored terrorists: Andhra CM

      PM Modi shaped new doctrine for India, issued warning to Pak-sponsored terrorists: Andhra CM

      Water row: Punjab govt seeks review of HC's May 6 order

      Water row: Punjab govt seeks review of HC's May 6 order

      Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.