Highlights

  • Sunak govt lost a crucial legal challenge
  • SC: deporting refugees to Rwanda unlawful
  • Deportation policy pushed by Braverman

Latest news

Samsung’s AI Smart Glasses Launch On December 10 With Gemini, 12MP Camera

Samsung’s AI Smart Glasses Launch On December 10 With Gemini, 12MP Camera

Apple AirPods 5 Review: The Regular AirPods Are No Longer Basic

Apple AirPods 5 Review: The Regular AirPods Are No Longer Basic

Infinix GT 50 Pro Review: The Most Ambitious Phone Infinix Has Made

Infinix GT 50 Pro Review: The Most Ambitious Phone Infinix Has Made

Apple’s New Diwali Film with Raw Mango Puts the iPhone 18 Pro’s Low-Light Filmmaking to the Test

Apple’s New Diwali Film with Raw Mango Puts the iPhone 18 Pro’s Low-Light Filmmaking to the Test

Oppo Pad Mini Review: The Ultimate Compact Android Tablet?

Oppo Pad Mini Review: The Ultimate Compact Android Tablet?

Dell 14S Launched In India With Core 7 Series 3 Chips, Starts At ₹79,990

Dell 14S Launched In India With Core 7 Series 3 Chips, Starts At ₹79,990

HP unveils OmniBook 5 and ProBook 4 G2iS with OLED displays and AI features

HP unveils OmniBook 5 and ProBook 4 G2iS with OLED displays and AI features

Google Dreambeans: An AI App That Makes Discovery Feel Personal

Google Dreambeans: An AI App That Makes Discovery Feel Personal

Apex court rules UK government policy to deport refugees to Rwanda unlawful

The appeal was lodged by the Braverman-led Home Office after a Court of Appeal decision similarly went against the government.

Apex court rules UK government policy to deport refugees to Rwanda unlawful

The UK government on Wednesday lost a crucial legal challenge after the Supreme Court in London ruled that its policy to deport refugees to Rwanda while their application for asylum is processed is unlawful.

The country’s highest court agreed with a previous Court of Appeal decision to say that there are "substantial grounds" to believe people deported to Rwanda could then be sent to places they would be unsafe by the Rwandan government.

It was one of the flagship policies championed by recently sacked home secretary Suella Braverman, who in a scathing pre-emptive letter had sought to lay the blame for such a ruling at the door of the Prime Minister Rishi Sunak – claiming he had “failed to prepare any sort of credible Plan B” to tackle the issue of illegal migration.

Sunak admitted it was “not the outcome” the government wanted as part of his "stop the boats" pledge but stressed that he had prepared for such an eventuality.

“We accept the Home Secretary’s submission that the Rwandan government entered into the agreement in good faith, and that the capacity of the Rwandan system to produce accurate and fair decisions can and will be built up,” notes the Supreme Court ruling.

“Nevertheless, asking ourselves whether there were substantial grounds for believing that a real risk of refoulment existed at the relevant time, we have concluded that there were. The changes needed to eliminate the risk of refoulement may be delivered in the future, but they have not been shown to be in place now. The Home Secretary’s appeal is therefore dismissed,” it concludes.

It will now be her successor, Home Secretary James Cleverly, who will be responsible for formulating the government’s response and strategy going forward.

“We have seen today’s judgment and will now consider next steps. This was not the outcome we wanted, but we have spent the last few months planning for all eventualities and we remain completely committed to stopping the boats,” Sunak said in a statement.

“Crucially, the Supreme Court – like the Court of Appeal and the High Court before it – has confirmed that the principle of sending illegal migrants to a safe third country for processing is lawful. This confirms the government’s clear view from the outset. Illegal migration destroys lives and costs British taxpayers millions of pounds a year. We need to end it and we will do whatever it takes to do so,” he said.

The unanimous judgment was read out by Lord Robert Reed, President of the Supreme Court, which the Rwandan government has “taken issue with”.

"This is ultimately a decision for the UK's judicial system. However, we do take issue with the ruling that Rwanda is not a safe third country for asylum seekers and refugees, in terms of refoulement," a Rwandan government spokesperson said.

The deportation scheme as part of a GBP 140-million pact with Rwanda was initially launched by former home secretary Priti Patel and designed to see those arriving in the UK illegally, including via small boats across the English Channel, deported to the east African nation.

Refugee charities have consistently called the proposal "inhumane" and claimed it breaks human rights laws, while Opposition parties have deemed the plan a "gimmick".

An injunction from the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) stopped the first flight of deportees to Rwanda from taking off in June last year and the scheme has been embroiled in litigation ever since, which means no asylum seekers have yet been deported to the country under the policy.

Frequently Asked Questions

The UK government tried to implement a policy to deport refugees to Rwanda while their application for asylum is processed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Up Next

Apex court rules UK government policy to deport refugees to Rwanda unlawful

Apex court rules UK government policy to deport refugees to Rwanda unlawful

Ukraine accuses US of helping Russia as missiles hit Kyiv

Ukraine accuses US of helping Russia as missiles hit Kyiv

'We're not giving up': Activist Thunberg joins France student protests

'We're not giving up': Activist Thunberg joins France student protests

Zelensky vows to respond as Moscow silent on 'energy ceasefire'

Zelensky vows to respond as Moscow silent on 'energy ceasefire'

Nepal Flash Floods Sweep Away 200 Houses, Five Bridges; Five People Missing

Nepal Flash Floods Sweep Away 200 Houses, Five Bridges; Five People Missing

Israel marks 3rd October 7 anniversary with tributes, Gaza strikes and election battle

Israel marks 3rd October 7 anniversary with tributes, Gaza strikes and election battle

ADVERTISEMENT

editorji-whatsApp

More videos

Heavy casualties in Ukraine after Russian strikes

Heavy casualties in Ukraine after Russian strikes

Israel puts military on alert for Oct 7 anniversary, warns Gazans

Israel puts military on alert for Oct 7 anniversary, warns Gazans

US-German trio wins medicine Nobel for work on optogenetics

US-German trio wins medicine Nobel for work on optogenetics

Passenger on rerouted Flydubai flight says pilot tried to crash plane

Passenger on rerouted Flydubai flight says pilot tried to crash plane

Flydubai Dubai-Tel Aviv Flight Diverted After Pilots Injured In Mid-Air Fight

Flydubai Dubai-Tel Aviv Flight Diverted After Pilots Injured In Mid-Air Fight

Trump offered to sell arms to Xi: US ambassador to Fox News

Trump offered to sell arms to Xi: US ambassador to Fox News

CNN, MS NOW, Politico allowed back in White House after judge's order

CNN, MS NOW, Politico allowed back in White House after judge's order

Trump hosts Xi Jinping for state dinner as pomp masks tensions

Trump hosts Xi Jinping for state dinner as pomp masks tensions

Israel's Netanyahu denounces enemies, allies in fiery UN speech

Israel's Netanyahu denounces enemies, allies in fiery UN speech

US judge blocks White House ban on CNN, MS NOW, Politico

US judge blocks White House ban on CNN, MS NOW, Politico

Editorji Technologies Pvt. Ltd. © 2022 All Rights Reserved.